For a nine-year-old girl known as Andy, a doe-hunting trip in the wintry Pennsylvania woods is meant to be a rite of passage into the world of her father. However, the journey becomes an unexpected and brutal confrontation with her own changing identity.
The hunt is a ritual designed to induct Andy into a male world of stoicism, violence, and dominance over nature. But Andy’s failure to shoot the doe is not a failure of character—it is a successful resistance to that induction. Kaplan subverts the classic hunting story (like Hemingway’s “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber”) by having the protagonist reject the kill. Doe Season By David Michael Kaplan Full Text
"Doe Season" by David Michael Kaplan, originally featured in The Atlantic , follows a young girl named Andy on a hunting trip that serves as a pivotal coming-of-age experience, forcing her to confront themes of gender identity, maturity, and the reality of death. The story explores her transition from childhood to womanhood as she reconciles her tomboy identity with the traumatic, visceral experience of killing a deer. For a nine-year-old girl known as Andy, a
“Doe Season” is a story about the bullet not fired. Its power lies in absence: the doe lives, but Andy’s childhood dies. Kaplan shows that growing up is not about learning to pull the trigger—it is about learning which triggers you refuse to pull. Andy’s final tears are not for the deer. They are for the girl who tried to be a boy, and for the father who could not see that she was already whole. But Andy’s failure to shoot the doe is
The full text of the story is typically available through college literature textbooks or in Kaplan's short story collection, Comfort . Share public link
If you're interested in reading the full text, I suggest checking out the following options:
David Michael Kaplan's short story " Doe Season " explores the transition from childhood innocence to adulthood as nine-year-old Andy joins a hunting trip, only to confront the harsh reality of death. The story, often studied for its rich symbolism and coming-of-age themes, tracks her journey from a tomboy persona to accepting her identity. It highlights her struggle with gender roles and the loss of innocence in the face of nature.